tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3928263351799361094.post948424707431344988..comments2023-10-30T19:01:07.501+05:30Comments on Abusaleh Shariff, Ph. D: Beyond the Bluster: Equity and Justice in West BengalAbusalehhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/00150857162132740494noreply@blogger.comBlogger2125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3928263351799361094.post-56346958506300944232011-05-01T12:50:29.126+05:302011-05-01T12:50:29.126+05:30Good one sir.Proceeed your works.Best wishes.Good one sir.Proceeed your works.Best wishes.mujeeb koduvallyhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/02139594771381428339noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3928263351799361094.post-25303795153911815612011-04-23T04:12:49.807+05:302011-04-23T04:12:49.807+05:30Respected Sir,
It is very interesting debate you h...Respected Sir,<br />It is very interesting debate you have initiated and being Muslim I want to share some thoughts with you.The so called Affirmative actions taken by the Government ( both Center and States)is very much debatable.The plight of Muslims all over India is more or less same. I have simple question to ask is that the deprivation of Muslims in West Bengal is due to Communists Rule or there are other causal factors are there ? It is not the Ruling Elite of India has systematically destroyed the traditional occupations of Muslims or they had discriminatory approach towards Muslim. For sake of reference i will site one article titled " Muslims In UP - 1947, 1967 and 1987" By Md.Aslam.it appeared in the edited book called "India- Creating a modern Nation". It is disappointing that Sachar Committee report is being utilized for the political end. The committee has erroneously did not talked about the land redistributin in Bengal. One simple statistics is that all over India 35.5% Muslim lives in urban and semi Urban area but Bengal has only 17%. How come they will not include the government paid Madarssa teacher as government employ. I think it was deliberate efforts of the Union Government to Malign the political alternative system. Today people have luxury to criticize Bengal Government and comparing with Gujarat Because they have lived in Communally Frictionless states for long time. What happened to Shining Muslims of the Gujarat who are living in the make shift tents in and around Ahmadabad. Currently I am living in Hyderabad and the M I M is representing this constituency for long time and if you have some time to inquire about the plight of Muslims in this constituency then you will realize that it is Muslim Elites who have exploited Poor Muslims and they have created such a system that the backwardness of Muslim perpetuate.zikrullahhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/09126973539449262077noreply@blogger.com